tiptrot.com
tiptrot.com November 20, 2017


Justices strike down citizenship law over gender differences

13 June 2017, 07:23 | Cynthia Sparks

Mark Wilson Getty Images

Mark Wilson  Getty Images

The Supreme Court took aim Monday at a gender distinction that makes birthright citizenship more hard for a child born overseas out of wedlock if only the father, not the mother, is an American. In the meantime, the five-year requirement "should apply, prospectively, to children born to unwed USA -citizen mothers".

Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg said the gender line Congress drew "is incompatible with the Constitution's guarantee of the equal protection of the laws to all persons".

The Supreme Court has struck down part of an unusual law that treats fathers and mothers differently when it comes to conferring citizenship on children born outside the U.S.

"Successful defense of legislation that differentiates on the basis of gender, we have reiterated, requires an 'exceedingly persuasive justification, '" Ginsburg wrote, quoting her own opinion in USA v. Virginia.

But an American mother must only have lived in the US continuously for one year before giving birth to a child to meet the requirement. But his father did not satisfy the five-year requirement.

She said federal law indicated Congress would have preferred to fix the discrepancy by instead applying the longer residency period to the children of American mothers. The U.S. Justice Department sought to defend the law and asked the high court to take the case. His father, who was unwed when Morales-Santana was born, was 20 days short of satisfying the five-year residency requirement. After oral argument, the justices were deadlocked 4-4, which left the lower court's ruling in the government's favor in place.

Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. and Justices Anthony M. Kennedy, Stephen G. Breyer, Sonia Sotomayor and Elena Kagan joined Ginsburg's opinion. Unwed American mothers, meanwhile, are only subject to a 1-year US residency requirement to give their children USA citizenship.


The law imposed different standards for acquiring citizenship for the offspring of an unwed USA citizen who has a child with a citizen of another nation.

Under federal law, a child born overseas to an unmarried American mother and non-American father could claim US citizenship if the mother lived continuously in the USA for a year at some point before the birth.

Congress can not legislate based on "once habitual, but now untenable" stereotypes about male domination, wrote Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, in Sessions v. Morales-Santana. Here, she observed, the more favorable treatment for unmarried US -citizen mothers rested on the idea that an unmarried mother was "the child's natural and sole guardian".

"Accepting, arguendo, that Congress intended the diverse physical-presence prescriptions to serve an interest in ensuring a connection between the foreign-born nonmarital child and the United States, the gender-based means scarcely serve the posited end", Ginsburg wrote.

The court was equally unimpressed with the government's second justification, which centered on a desire to ensure that a child born outside the United States to an unmarried USA -citizen parent would not be "stateless" - that is, lacking any citizenship at all.

But while the court struck down the gender differences in the law, Ginsburg said the longer five-year period should continue apply to both mothers and fathers until Congress decides on a different length of time.



Other News

Trending Now

Donald Trump Finally Supports NATO Defense Agreement With US Allies
Top administration officials, including Vice President Pence, have since said the United States is committed to Article 5. According to the statement sent to ACTMedia, the American-Romanian Business Council (AMRO) applauds President Donald J.

Jennifer Lawrence private plane suffers twin engine failure
News talked to a Lawrence representative who confirmed that she was on board and was not injured in the incident. Jennifer Lawrence is okay after her plane was forced to make an emergency landing due to both engines failing.

Top aides to Theresa May resign after British election losses
Publicly and privately the blame game has begun for the Conservatives after failing to win a majority at the general election. Indeed it's said apart from her husband, Nick Timothy and Fiona Hill , were the only people she listened to.

Trump lashes out at London's mayor, again
Trump launched an attack on the London Mayor, while apparently misconstruing a statement made by him post the incident. Khan's spokesman repeated his response of a day earlier: "Nothing has changed since yesterday".

Spicer refers Russia investigation questions to Trump's outside attorney
Be proactive - Use the "Flag as Inappropriate" link at the upper right corner of each comment to let us know of abusive posts. A majority of Americans - 61 percent - think Trump does more harm than good when he speaks on behalf of his administration.

In foreign policy shift, Canada decides it's not worth appeasing Trump
Freeland said, and will on Wednesday release details on spending plans for a new defense policy. Canada plans to strengthen its military presence in the most risky parts of the world, Ms.

Asean's May PMI signals weaker improvement as performance slips
UK May manufacturing PMI dipped only slightly to 56.7 from 57.3 in the previous month, broadly in line with expectations. Manufacturing PMI of over 50.0 indicates expansion in the economy.

WWDC '17: First look at Apple's new iMac Pro
Prices are sticking at US$1,099 for the entry level 21.5-inch iMac , while the top-end 27-inch 5K model stays at $1,799. They also get a pair of USB-C ports, while retaining legacy ports - no repeat of the MacBook Pro dongle debacle.

Catfish tosser says he was 'dumb redneck with a bad idea'
Guentzel, who scored the victor in Game 1 , now has the second-highest goal total ever recorded by a rookie in one playoff season. The second game for the most part we played well, but this is a winning business and at the end of the day you just have to win.

Ghani to Allow Taliban Office if Afghan Peace Takes Root
A man injured in the May 31 Kabul truck bombing that killed over 150 is carried to an ambulance. Afghan authorities have said Pakistan was involved in the attack, charges denied by Islamabad.